Maul Shadow Lord vs The Penguin villain crime drama comparison editorial banner

MAUL – SHADOW LORD Could Be Star Wars’ Answer to The Penguin

Soeren Kamper discussion, editorial, Maul: Shadow Lord, tv series

There’s a growing feeling that MAUL – SHADOW LORD isn’t just another animated Star Wars project — it might be Lucasfilm’s version of what The Penguin became for Batman.

Not in tone copy-paste.
Not in setting.

But in structure, character focus, and the kind of story being told.

And the parallels are kind of hard to ignore.

A Villain From a Hit Film, Finally Center Stage

Both shows take a character who debuted as a secondary villain in a major movie… and ask the question:

What happens after the fall?

  • Oswald “Oz” Cobb rose from the wreckage of Gotham’s criminal underworld after The Batman
  • Maul clawed his way back from death, exile, and humiliation after The Phantom Menace

Neither story is about a polished crime boss at the top.
They’re about ambition in motion.

These are ground-level crime empire origin stories — messy, violent, strategic, and personal.

Maul isn’t ruling.
He’s building.

And that’s where the tension lives.

A Key Female Character Inside the Empire

Another major similarity is the introduction of a central female figure tied directly to the criminal rise.

In The Penguin, we get Sofia Gigante — a character with her own power, trauma, and agenda, who isn’t just decoration in Oz’s world.

In MAUL – SHADOW LORD, that role appears to be filled by Devon Izara.

This signals something important:
The show isn’t just about Maul being scary.

It’s about alliances, manipulation, loyalty, and emotional leverage inside the underworld. Crime stories work best when power is personal — and these characters are positioned to be part of the engine, not background.

Exploring Villains Without “Redeeming” Them

This might be the biggest parallel.

Neither show is trying to turn its lead into a misunderstood hero.

Instead, the goal is something more interesting:

Understanding a villain ≠ excusing them

  • The Penguin digs into Oz’s psychology, insecurity, and need for control
  • Shadow Lord looks poised to explore Maul’s rage, obsession, abandonment, and need for purpose after losing everything

We’re not watching a redemption arc.
We’re watching a character double down on becoming what they are.

That’s prestige storytelling territory — morally gray, emotionally layered, but still firmly villain-driven.

Street-Level Power, Not Galactic War

Another shared DNA strand: scale.

This isn’t Jedi vs. Sith destiny stuff.
This is crime, territory, leverage, survival.

The Penguin stayed grounded in Gotham’s underworld politics.
Shadow Lord looks ready to live in:

  • criminal networks
  • power vacuums
  • manipulation
  • shadow operations

That’s a side of Star Wars fans have wanted explored in depth for years.

Why This Is a Smart Direction for Star Wars

Star Wars has legendary villains.
But it rarely slows down long enough to examine them as people navigating power structures.

If MAUL – SHADOW LORD lands this tone correctly, it could:

  • Expand Star Wars into prestige crime-drama territory
  • Deepen one of the saga’s most psychologically intense characters
  • Show the underworld as more than just a backdrop for heroes

It wouldn’t just be “more Maul.”

It would be Star Wars proving it can tell character-driven villain stories at a high level — the same way DC did with The Penguin.

And that’s a lane the franchise hasn’t fully owned yet.

Stay connected with the galaxy’s latest updates!

Follow us on X, Facebook, Instagram, bsky or Pinterest for exclusive content, mod guides, Star Wars gaming news, and more. Your support helps keep the Holonet alive—one click at a time.